Oh yes once again it’s been too long. Let’s see, since Pride, what have I been up to?
– Learning to jump rope. Yup, you heard me. I wasn’t a very good girl back in the day. I think there was a jump rope somewhere in my house but along with roller skates, cartwheels, and hula hoops, I just didn’t excel at the little girly physical activities that everyone else got to do. I could write a whole sad post about how my family was into shaming us about our bodies, and how I learned to keep as still as possible so I could forget I had a body at all, but there’s been enough rain recently. But I’m quite proud of myself — I picked up the basics of jumping rope in a few minutes, which gives me hope. Who wants to teach me to hoop??
– Today in Copley Square, as I was walking to the farmer’s market in search of native strawberries (OMG the best I’ve ever had by the way) I saw a gorgeous butch/femme couple having their wedding photos taken (by a cute dykey photographer no less) and I yelled out “congratulations!”. They were both just beaming, looking beautiful and so happy. I was so thrilled I got goosebumps. This is what it’s all about, you know? How can I be anti-marriage when it’s out there making people that happy? But I digress, this isn’t supposed to be an angsty post.
– I’ve been reading and re-reading an essay by Karen Bullock-Jordan, in the anthology This is what lesbian looks like from 1999, which I first read a few months ago (witness the $5 library fine I had to pay today in order to renew it…). In a footnote, she explains her use of the phrase ’sexual preference’ instead of ’sexual orientation’, saying that sexual orientation’s “coinage and usage was part of the strategy that moved us into a civil rights framework, the idea being that if we fuck others of the same sex because we are oriented that way, then we are more deserving of civil rights. Choice has been completely discounted. In my opinion, the orientation argument seems to be little more than Don’t be mean to us poor homosexuals. We can’t help it. It is important to also argue for the right of an individual to choose homosexuality if that makes sense to them.” (p. 38)
Her argument opened my eyes to the many times I’ve used the orientation argument myself, but I’ve stopped since reading that. She is calling for sexual liberation, rightly eliding homophobia with erotophobia. She points out at the end of the essay, “There are no laws against emotional love between those of the same sex, only against fucking them.” (p. 45) Her words have helped me clarify my own position on these issues — sex is something that is always used against the LGBTQ movement. Talking about our relationships has been called obscene by conservatives (especially religious ones) because ‘it’s automatically about sex’. Which is ridiculous, really. The word liberation has a lot of meaning for me — I feel like I am slowly liberating myself from the stifling cloak of self-doubt and embarrassment about my body and my desires, and the more liberated I get the more I wish that everyone could be that way too.
– I’m working up a post about the firestorm of controversy around the Top Hot Butches list, and will have it up this weekend. There’s a lot to be said on both sides of the argument, and as usual I feel torn between conflicting viewpoints. However, I was appalled by how much butch-hating was going on, and it only strengthened my feeling that this work has hardly begun. If you want a taste of my opinion, look here.
– Oh yeah and one more thing, I’m SO SAD that we can’t go down to NY for pride! Last year we got thoroughly soaked at the dyke march but loved it anyway. Too bad we’re moving and M. has to work. We’ll be there in spirit.
8 responses so far ↓
Jess // June 26, 2009 at 3:54 pm |
Great post FG, and definitely a great response to the Top Hot Butches controversy.
I am sad that you cant make it to NY pride too!
Jumping rope is great exercise! Good luck with that
greg // June 26, 2009 at 3:55 pm |
You picked it out and called it out. And you were right. I’m not surprised at all, just impressed as always that you are able to see so clearly.
Jumping rope is something that I’ve been meaning to get back into – it’s so good for you but very exhausting. Go for it!
Blazer // June 26, 2009 at 4:03 pm |
I haven’t been following this “debate” as closely as some, but did read several posts on Sinclair’s site. When Sinclair ran the poll on our opinion of the usefullness of labels, I was in the camp of “not in love with them but find them usefull at times”. I am rethinking that position now.
Having come out in the early 80s during the height of the feminist movement, I am very familiar with the challenges of using politically correct language and demanding that others do as well. Words like “girl”, “gal”, “chick”, and “dyke” were erased from our vocabulary. All of those words seem to have been allowed to return used in proper context and with proper intent.
Now I am faced with this whole new vocabulary(some of which I feel I need a queer dictionary to translate), and I am hesitent to “label” myself for fear of offending someone else. If I call myself a “butch” (which I have up until now), will I offend someone who doesn’t feel I am quite masculine enough to fit the category?
I feels as though maybe the labeling thing has gotten out of control. If we agree that sexuality and gender are fluid and don’t fit a binary model then we can never create/adopt enough labels include all of us accurately.
Holden // June 26, 2009 at 4:17 pm |
Excellent response to the controversy around the Top Hot Butches list FG. I look forward to reading your post about it.
B // June 26, 2009 at 5:30 pm |
Great to see you posting again. I have to admit, I don’t really look at butches that much, just my J. (I know, I’m weird) BUT I can honestly say that k.d. lang takes my breath away.
boychick1 // June 26, 2009 at 7:37 pm |
I hate labels – this is one reason why. Maybe someday we can just refer to ourselves as humans – and we won’t (in fun or otherwise) need to create the “100 hottest humans” list.
Tina-cious.com // June 27, 2009 at 7:44 am |
Umm. Hi.
e // June 29, 2009 at 11:04 am |
I was a little surprised and dismayed by the firestorm (or did you call it a shitstorm?) around the top hot butches as well. Ugh. I thought it was supposed to be about sharing the love…
Jump rope = fun! Try the hula hoop, too!