What is femme to me? The title of this post is something that M. started calling me, perhaps having to do with my pronouncements about hurricanes. I think it’s accurate — we were also talking about why it is that the attention from straight guys is much, much less than it could be (and has been in the past), and she said it’s partly because I can be intimidating. It’s true — I have actually sneered at straight men who give me the eyeball.
So I am finally answering the question posted here; it’s something I’ve recently been thinking about a lot. I have sometimes been tempted to define it in opposition to other things — not straight, not butch, not bi — but I’d rather try to think about it more positively here.
Femme was unconscious for me for so many years, and was marked by the contrast between my gf and me. I wore dresses, M. wore pants. M. opened doors, I walked gracefully through them. I suppose on some level neither of us knew another way to be, another model for a romantic relationship; there were boys, and there were girls, and if you were both girls you had to pretend one was a boy so you’d know what to do.
But it was actually much more complicated than that, because looking back, very few of the straight relationships around us modeled that kind of gentleman/lady interaction. I mean, she brought me flowers on a regular basis. She opened the car door for me. She made all but one of many first moves. She paid for our dates (I didn’t have a job, but I suspect even if I had she still would have paid). And I was fine with that — no ‘I’m an independent woman!’ business here, at least not at first.
I think it was in about 2006 when I read the first chapter or so of Stone Butch Blues; I dimly saw myself reflected there, but I had no idea that it was possible to have those identities now. I thought those relationships were relics of a different time, and I didn’t really allow myself to apply them to me.
So it wasn’t until this spring that I started to think of myself as a femme, when I finally found the queer blogging community and got to participate for the first time in discussions around butch/femme dynamics. And from there it gets a little complicated, because at first I was thrilled — finally, a way to talk about my experience that included all the different aspects of my life; the hitting on by straight guys, the invisibility within the queer community, the lack of ability to tone down the femininity, even when it’s warranted, the deep and abiding attraction to masculine women. And I was ecstatic for maybe two months, and then the insecurity started.
Talk of submissive bottoming made me feel weird — was I submissive enough in bed to be a femme? And then the skirts and heels — do I wear them often enough to count as a femme? Do I remove enough hair to be a femme? Before anyone jumps on this, let me qualify: it’s not really my identity as a femme I was worried about, it was my image. I know I can be a femme as long as I want to claim that word; but what will other people think? Does my femininity have enough queer signifiers?
It shouldn’t matter. Most of the time it doesn’t. But in all these discussions of what makes a femme a femme, we are bound to call the value of each of our individualities and decisions into question. Unless we all look identical, we will all have a different way of expressing our femininity, and sometimes we won’t agree on what is constitutive of femininity. Nor should we!
But back to the original question: what is femme to me?
Femme is not being victimized by my womanhood. Femme is not being limited by my womanhood.
Femme is being strong, self-sufficient, smart. Femme is taking ownership of my sexuality, and not letting other people control it or control me through it. Femme is acknowledging my power as a woman. Femme is embracing all aspects of myself, including the masculine ones; it is not being afraid to allow masculinity and femininity to coexist within one feminine, womanly body. Femme is validating and supporting other people’s choices and genders, and expecting mine to be validated and supported too. Femme is loving my butch beyond reason. Femme is uncompromisingly working toward equality and justice, even though that means being in constant conflict with the people in power. Femme is being part of a community with a history, standing in opposition of people’s expectations of us. Femme is being myself, unafraid.